As part of the CAW Wrestling Observer, the C.W.O rates each match out of 5 Stars to determine just how good they were, based off of: storytelling, coordination, action, etc. These matches have scored a 5 Star rating, or even above, by the heads of the CAW Wrestling Observer DoggyDog & PME Morales, due to their outstanding coordination and storytelling and their action packed wrestling skills.
6 Star Match
This is a special rating given by DoggyDog & PME Morales for matches that exceeded the 5 Star Rating System due to it's excellence. Only 4 Matches in all history of CAW have earned this rating.
- YWE WrestleMania 4: The Undertaker vs. Mr. Black
- YWE WrestleMania 5: Mr. Black vs. Blue Star
- DWF WrestleMania 2: Francaios (c) vs. Roacher vs. DoggyDog
- AWC G1 Climax I Tokyo Dome 2017: Arrow vs. Amber
5.5 Star Match
One of the more rare ratings in CWO, only one match has achieved this rating.
- AWC/DWF/TWE Clash Of The Worlds: RockyN vs Johnny Extreme
5.25 Star Match
Another of the more rare ratings in CWO, only one match has achieved this rating.
- EWE Summerslam S04: Arrow vs Roacher
List of 5 Star Matches
YWE:
- YWE Wrestlemania 6: The Undertaker vs. Phenom
- YWE WrestleMania 2: Blue Star vs. Shawn Michaels
- YWE Summerslam 2011: Mr. Black vs. Blue Star
- YWE Summerslam 2011: Phsycoz (c) vs. Double D
- YWE Hell In A Cell 2011: Phsycoz vs. Double D
- YWE WrestleMania 3: Victor X (c) vs. Phenom
- YWE WrestleMania 3: Angel (c) vs. Mr. Black
- YWE Over The Limit 2012: Mr. Black (c) vs. Angel
- YWE Summerslam 2012: Victor X vs. Phsycoz
- YWE Summerslam 2012: Phenom (c) vs. Double D
- YWE TLC 2012: Victor X (c) & Phsycoz vs. Mr. Black & Angel
- YWE WrestleMania 4: Victor X (c) vs. Angel vs. Phsycoz
- YWE WrestleMania 4: Double D (c) vs. PJ Skillz
- YWE Summerslam 2013: Blue Star vs. Angel
- YWE Royal Rumble 2014: Crazy One (c) vs. PJ Skillz
- YWE WrestleMania 5: PJ Skillz (c) vs. Antho
- YWE Over The Limit 2014: Phenom vs. Mario Sanchez
- YWE All Extreme 2014: Shadow (c) vs. Phenom
- YWE Wrestlemania 6: Victor X (c) vs. Silvio
DWF:
- DWF Hell In A Cell S01: AJ Reyes vs. DoggyDog
- DWF WrestleMania 1: Rocky'N (c) vs. PJ Skillz
- DWF WrestleMania 1: DoggyDog (c) vs. Arrow
- DWF Money In The Bank S02: Arrow (c) vs. Rocky'N
- DWF Summerslam S02: Arrow (c) vs. Amazing Troy
- DWF Summerslam S02: Rocky'N (c) vs. Shawn vs. AJ Reyes
- DWF Hell In A Cell S02: K2K (c) vs. AJ Reyes
- DWF WrestleMania 2: Rocky'N (c) vs. Shawn
- DWF Money In The Bank S03: K2K (c) vs. Arrow
- DWF Money In The Bank S03: Triple X (c) vs. AJ Reyes
- DWF Summerslam S03: Roacher (c) vs. Mike House
- DWF Summerslam S03: BerSeck (Hunter, Blade & Savior) (c) vs. Vandy Phoeuk, Casablanca & Maxakrer
- DWF No Way Out S03: Max Mercury (c) vs Brett Storm
- DWF Wrestlemania 3: Shawn (c) v. Hunter
- DWF Wrestlemania 3: DoggyDog v. Mr. Black
YCW:
- YCW/DWF Invasion: Mr. Black vs. Mario Sanchez
EWE:
- EWE Survivor Series S03: Triple X & SWED (Roacher & Francaios) vs. RFT (Mario Sanchez, AJ Reyes, & Arrow)
- EWE Royal Rumble S04: Rocky'N (c) vs. Arrow
- EWE WrestleMania 3: Phenom (c) vs. Mario Sanchez
- EWE WrestleMania 3: Scott Jay vs. Arrow
- EWE Summerslam S04: Shawn (c) vs. K2K
RpW:
- RpW WrestleMania 1: DoggyDog (c) vs. Jake Navor
- RpW Summerslam S02: Casablanca vs. Matt
- RpW Hell In A Cell S02: Casablanca vs. Matt
- RpW Royal Rumble S02: Mr. X (c) vs. Francaios
- RpW Wrestlemania 2: Roacher (c) v. Francaios
YXW:
- YXW Madison Square Garden S01: DoggyDog (c) vs. Mario Sanchez
- YXW Road to Gold: Max Mercury (c) vs. Brett Storm
- YXW Redemption: Brett Storm (c) vs. Herosta
AWC:
- AWC Money In The Bank 2016: Rocky'N (c) vs. Chris Zero vs. PJ Skillz.
- AWC Unforgiven 2016: Shawn vs. Mario Sanchez.
- AWC G1 Climax Day 2 B Block 2016: Roacher vs. Shawn.
- AWC G1 Climax Day 4 B Block 2016: Scott Jay vs. Mario Sanchez.
- AWC G1 Climax I Tokyo Dome 2017: Hunter vs. Jason Cage.
- AWC ECW Death Games 2017: Mega Stars vs SWED.
- AWC ECW Death Games 2017: Mega Stars vs Zero-1 (c).
- AWC No Mercy 2017: Shawn (c) vs. Rocky'N vs. Mario Sanchez.
- AWC Payback 2017: Shawn (c) vs. Roacher.
- AWC Manhatten Mayhem 2017: Max (c) vs. Hardcore Brody
- AWC The Great American Bash 2017: Jason Cage (c) vs. DoggyDog.
- AWC All Star Weekend II: Phenom vs Scott Jay.
- AWC All Star Weekend II: Shawn (c) vs. Hunter vs. Casablanca.
- AWC King Of Pro-Wrestling 2018: Arrow (c) vs Matt.
- AWC Armageddon 2018: Shawn (c) v. Mario Sanchez v. Scott Jay.
- AWC Summerslam 2018: Arrow (c) v. Mercury
- AWC Summerslam 2018: Shawn (c) v. Casablanca
XWP:
- XWP Wrestlemania 1: Heaven's Sexiest Angels (Angel Alexander, Stunning Bradd, & Mr. Macho) (c) vs. Chris Danger, Jake Navor, & Connor
- XWP Outlaw S02: Arrow (c) vs. DoggyDog
- XWP Survivor Series II: Brett Storm (c) vs. Matteo
- XWP WrestleMania 2: Stunning Bradd (c) vs. Mr. Macho vs. Angel Alexander
- XWP NXT Take Over: Dublin: Brendan X (c) vs. Rocky Crippler vs. Shawn Sokolov
- XWP Summerslam S03: Mr Macho (c) vs Angel Alexander
- XWP Psychopath S03: Jacob Cass & Anthony Payne (c) vs SWED (Francaios & Roacher)
- XWP Nightmares S03: Sean Avery (c) vs Mr Macho
- XWP Survivor Series S03: Sean Avery (c) vs Angel Alexander
- All-Star Tournament First Round: Angel Alexander vs Mr Macho
- All-Star Tournament Second Round: Shawn vs Jacob Cass
Total Impact:
- Total Impact Extreme Rules: Jake Navor vs Brett Storm (c)
NHBW:
- NHBW Blitzkrieg: Nick Rich vs Angel Alexander
- NHBW War of Supremacy: Quincy Demont (c) vs Aaron Young
- NHBW War of Supremacy: Clark The Great (c) vs Brett Storm vs Maximus Mondragon
TWE:
- TWE Unforgiven: SWED (Francaios & Roacher) (c) vs. Attitude Honor (Mario Sanchez & Scott Jay)
ENA:
- ENA Battleground 2017: Ahmi del Razek (c) vs. DoggyDog
- ENA Summerslam 2017: Nuru vs. J.B Black
- ENA Wrestlemania 5: Herosta v. Jacob Cass
IWA:
- IWA Summerslam S02: The Arising (Angel Alexander, Brett Storm, Mahadi Khan, Matteo & Mohammad Khan) (c) vs DoggyDog, SWED (Roacher & Francaios), Max Mercury & Demon Spyke
- IWA Survivor Series S02: The Arising (Angel Alexander (c), Brett Storm (c), Mahadi Khan (c), Matteo, Mohammad Khan (c) & Sean Avery (c)) vs Team Bring It (DoggyDog & Arrow), SWED (Francaios & Roacher), Max Mercury (c) & Flamer
- IWA Royal Rumble S02: DoggyDog (c) vs Arrow
PWF:
- PWF Noche De Campeones: DoggyDog v. Mario Sanchez
PASW:
- PASW Breaking Point 2018: Adrian Destiny (c) v. Mario Sanchez